KCSE 2023/2024 LEAKAGE; LIST OF PROPOSED CHANGES TO REDUCE KNEC KCSE EXAM MALPRACTICES/ LEAKAGE
The release of the 2022 KCSE examination results in January 2023 raised an eyebrow among interested key education stakeholders. This is after little-known schools from Nyanza region dethroned seasoned academic giants like Kapsabet High, Mang’u and Alliance. Top in the KCSE 2022- January 2023 academic chart was Nyambaria Boys High School and Cardinal Otunga Boys High School. Click HERE to check the list of the Top 100 schools nationally in the KCSE 2022-January 2023 Results.
The unprecedented changes in the list of Top 100 schools nationally prompted the National assembly education committee to unearth examination malpractice allegations in a bid to salvage the credibility of KCSE certificates issued to candidates following the release of KCSE results.
Henceforth, the following changes have been proposed to reduce or end KCSE leakages:
Auditing the examination process periodically- after two years just like in the universities.
According to the experts, the security of the examinations starts from setting and administering all the way to marking. Consequently, proposals have been made to exempt practising teachers from the process due to a conflict of interest.
Examination centres should be moved outside learning institutions with the enhancement of security personnel and the use of CCTV during the examination period.
The experts also want the government to consider switching off the mobile network in cheating-prone centres.
KNEC has been challenged to work towards automation of exams administration and grading in future, where students use biometrics, something they say may be expensive but worth investing in.
Below are the full details of the proceedings aimed at reducing KCSE examination cheating:
KNEC IN TROUBLE OVER CHEATING ALLEGATIONS
The Julius Melly-led committee on Thursday met various education stakeholders to try and seal loopholes of exam malpractice.
“Universities…I know you have engineers, you have doctors, lawyers…yet you have managed to bring down the competition, what do we do in order to bring down the cutthroat competition in KCSE?” Posed Melly, who is the Tinderet MP.
Prof. Paul Muoki of the Kenya Universities Quality Assurance Network (KUQAN) responded: “We periodically audit the process, we suggest that maybe after every two years, independent auditors from KNEC come out and audit the process. Maybe the report can be tabled even before your committee for purposes of making sure what KNEC is doing so, currently, we don’t do that…this has really worked very well in our universities and whenever reports are done they are submitted all the way to the university council.”
According to the experts, the security of the examinations starts from setting and administering all the way to marking, with proposals made that practising teachers should be exempted due to conflict of interest.
They are also suggesting that examination centres should be moved outside learning institutions with the enhancement of security personnel and the use of CCTV during the examination period.
The experts also want the government to consider switching off the mobile network in cheating-prone centres.
The University of Nairobi (UoN) lecturer Dr Michael Mungai opined: “Bringing other people to set exams who are not teachers, I think there we can talk of not practising teachers because you can be a teacher but a Member of Parliament so you are not practising and you could be a professional in that area, therefore, bringing experts to set exams.”
Education expert Amos Kaburu stated: “Are our assessments measuring intelligence or exposure to content? In all fairness, examinations in this country are a measure of exposure to content, that’s why if you have not completed the syllabus you will fail, if you have not read for exams you will fail.
So it’s not a matter of intelligence because for the intelligence you need to remove all extraneous variables and the residual value remaining is purely your intelligence, but the KNEC exams can’t do that because it is the convolution of both normal as well as criteria reference.”
KNEC has been challenged to work towards automation of exams administration and grading in future, where students use biometrics, something they say may be expensive but worth investing in.
“We do these exams as a do or die, when I am sick in bed why should I do a KCSE exam? When I’m delivering a baby and I want to rest, you are told sit for an exam in a ward…these are issues we need to address once and for all,” added MP Melly.
KASNEB boss Dr Nicholas Leting stated: “Using my biometric, I have to use my finger to press it on so that it identifies me as a candidate the way we use in IEBC when we go to vote…so I check in the system and it identifies it is a Dr Leting sitting for this exams and it uses what we call proctoring technology so that if I attempt to wink to my colleague in the room, the system can detect body movement and switch off the computer.”
SOURCE: CITIZEN TV DIGITAL